Trial Lawyers Association Image
Avvo Image
Attorney Jessica Image

Attorney Jessica Rutzick

Jessica Rutzick has worked as a trial lawyer since 1997 and has a diverse and accomplished background in which she has obtained successful results in state and federal district courts as well as the Wyoming Supreme Court and the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals. Jessica offers a vast amount of trial experience and intelligent legal strategy and reasoning. Click here to learn more.

WELCOME TO Jessica Rutzick & Associates, P.C.

Twenty years ago, Jessica Rutzick committed her career to helping people through difficult, life-changing events–all involving lawsuits.Car wrecks, work-place injuries and insurance denials all cause tremendous financial and emotional stress. Jessica devotes her law practice to meet each of your individual needs and concerns. She loves to take on the largest corporations and powerful insurance companies. In her personal injury practice, Jessica identifies and explains system failures and uses her knowledge to hold your adversaries accountable. In addition to compelling results, Jessica provides closure, allowing you to move forward with your life.In addition to legal complications and frustrations involving insurance claims, there are a number of other issues you may be dealing with in which legal assistance can be of invaluable benefit. Whether you have been the victim of a serious injury or you need help with legal issues arising from your business, we have the resources and skills to provide you with the help you need. We have, in the past, helped to represent clients whose cases involve:

Insurance Companies We Have Sued

  • Cigna Health
  • Life Insurance of North America
  • Starr Indemnity
  • Companion Life
  • Unum Provident
  • Aetna
  • Hartford Life and Accident Insurance Company
  • Mutual of Omaha
  • American Medical and Life Insurance Company
  • Protective Insurance Company
  • Baldwin & Lyons
  • WINHealth
  • Stewart Title
  • Guardian Life Insurance Company of North America
  • The Standard Insurance Company
  • United States Fire Insurance Company
  • Fairmont Specialty
  • Liberty Life Assurance Company
  • Reserve National
  • State Farm
  • Liberty Mutual
  • Midwest Family Mutual Ins. Co.


Whether your insurance claim has been improperly denied or delayed or you need help getting compensation for a serious injury, we can help you fight for your rights under the law and ensure that your best interests are fully upheld. Contact Jessica Rutzick & Associates today to Talk with a member of our well-qualified legal staff and learn more about what we can do for you.

Jessica’s preparation for my case was very impressive. She uncovered facts, analyzed similar cases, conducted focus groups to simulate jury responses. Her execution was even more impressive. Logical, aggressive, and did not put up with he opposing attorney’s efforts to throw things off. She is a winner.

- Smart, prepared, cares about her clients

Jessica is a very experienced and knowledgeable attorney. She and her staff are very helpful and skilled. I have co-counseled with Jessica on legal matters and have referred her cases that were outside my area of practice, with good outcomes.

- Jason Majors

Jessica co-counseled a bad faith case with me and did a great job. Her skills and tenacity added value to the case. Hard worker and competent.

- Nevin Seeger

Every now and then even a lawyer needs to hire another lawyer to represent them personally. Jessica Rutzick is the lawyer I rely on when I need outside counsel. She’s a lawyer’s lawyer; capable, knowledgeable, aggressive when she needs to be, but also capable of calm, insightful negotiation. She will get the job done.

- George Phocas

Jessica Rutzick is incredibly sharp, responsive, and an excellent communicator. Thoroughly impressed with the attention to detail she and her team exercised in my denied medical claim case!

- Raina Steinmeier

My son was in an automobile accident in 2007, he compressed and fractured a vertebrae in his low back. The only pain relief was a treatment called Radiofrequency Denervation (RF); it is a very expensive and painful procedure where they burn the nerves. Blue Cross/Blue Shield of North Carolina paid for four treatments, and on the fifth one they denied his claim saying it was “medically unnecessary”. We appealed and won. The next RF was denied for the same reason. We appealed and it was denied. That meant we needed to prepare for a second level appeal. I just didn’t have it in me – ever since the accident it has been a constant battle with BC/BS NC, and by this time I was mentally exhausted. I contacted our insurance commissioner for help; they referred me to Jessica Rutzick. My first thought was that we didn’t have the money to hire an attorney, especially one eight hours away in Jackson Hole, Wyoming – I had no choice but to call her. I spoke with her assistant Linda and told/cried her my story. I was dealing with my son in pain and an insurance company that didn’t care. Linda was so nice and caring she put me at ease and said she would discuss our situation with Jessica and get back with me. She called me back with awesome news that Jessica would take our case! I needed to mail them copies of all of the documentation I had (two 3” binders full) right away as Jessica was leaving on vacation in a couple weeks. The appeal deadline was approaching and she would need to get started right away. Jessica spent a full Sunday (her day off) getting started on our case. She was totally awesome and fully committed to our case – her staff was in constant touch with me. I still get teary-eyed when I think of how she lifted the burden off my shoulders and took charge of the situation. Most people would have told me they didn’t have time for us, but not Jessica.

Our Christmas present that year was an email from Jessica:
“BCBS NC just called and told me they approved the medical benefits sought for the treatments, so the appeal was successful. Happy Holidays. Jessica.”

Hopefully we won’t have to, but if we need to, we would definitely use her services again. We highly recommend Jessica and her staff! Jessica Rutzick is our Angel!

- Woo Hoo Jessica Won Our Case!

As a large business owner the past 25 years i have had the opportunity to interact with many lawyers on wide variety of issues ranging from simple employment matters to complex business transactions, etc. i can without heistation say that Jessica is the best litigator i have ever had the opportunity to work with, thus i can unequivocally recomend her and her firm!

- Outstanding Lawyer